Quick answer: keep one shared record of every pitch, kept by client and show together, with a fixed list of stages, one owner per pitch, and a follow-up date on everything that isn't finished. Follow up on day 3 and day 7, then stop and snooze the show for 3 to 6 months. Review replies and follow-ups on a set weekly rhythm, and report bookings per client. A spreadsheet or Airtable works to start; a podcast outreach workspace such as Podseeker keeps that record for you, because the shows, pitches, follow-ups and replies all run through it from your own inbox.
This guide is for small agencies and independent publicists who pitch several clients to podcasts and share the work between two or three people. For deciding which shows go to which client, and avoiding conflicts between clients, see how to manage podcast outreach for multiple clients.
What Should Every Pitch Record Contain?
Most small agencies start with email threads spread across inboxes and a sheet that's out of date by Wednesday. The fix is one record per pitch that everyone reads from. Keep it short; a field nobody fills in is worse than no field.
| Field | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Client | The same show can fit two clients. Track the client and the show together, never the show alone. |
| Podcast | The show name and a link, so anyone on the team can open it. |
| Contact | The host or producer you emailed, and the address you used. |
| Angle | The one idea you pitched, so a follow-up or a handoff doesn't contradict it. |
| Owner | The teammate who sent the pitch and answers the replies. |
| Stage | Where the pitch is now, from a fixed list (below). |
| Last email | The date of the last message you sent. |
| Next step | What happens next and when: a follow-up date, a recording date, or "snoozed until March". |
| Outcome | Booked, declined, or no reply, with the date. This is what you report. |
The most common mistake is tracking podcasts instead of pitches. A show you pitched for one client in March can be a good fit for another client in May, so the history has to live with the client and the show together.
Which Stages Should Your Podcast Outreach Pipeline Use?
Agree on one list of stages and don't let anyone invent their own. A pitch is in exactly one stage at a time, and every stage has an obvious next step:
| Stage | It moves here when | What happens next |
|---|---|---|
| Shortlisted | The show is active, interviews outside guests, and fits the client | Find the right contact and write the pitch |
| Pitched | The first email is sent | First follow-up on day 3 if there's no reply |
| Following up | One or two follow-ups are sent | Stop after the second follow-up (day 7) |
| In conversation | The host or producer replies | Answer within a working day; agree on a date |
| Booked | A recording date is agreed | Prepare the client; log the date |
| Recorded / released | The episode is recorded, then published | Share it with the client; plan promotion |
| Declined | The host says no | Thank them; note the reason |
| Snoozed | No reply after two follow-ups, or "not right now" | Look again in 3 to 6 months, ideally with a new angle |
"Snoozed" matters more than it looks. A show that didn't answer is not a no: hosts' schedules change, and a new angle months later often lands. Without a snooze date, those shows are either pestered or forgotten.
When Should You Follow Up, and When Should You Stop?
Follow up on day 3, then once more on day 7 if there's no reply, in the same thread. Then stop: three emails in total. Follow-ups are worth the effort. In Podseeker's State of Podcast Pitching 2026 data, 22.6% of bookings and 27.9% of conversations began only after a follow-up. Most hosts who answer do it quickly: the median first reply arrives within 2 days, and 90% within 28 days.
Stop the sequence as soon as the host replies, the email bounces, or the host declines. A follow-up that lands after a host has already answered is the fastest way to look careless. For wording, see how to follow up on a podcast pitch, with four templates.
Who Owns Each Pitch on a Small Team?
One person owns each pitch from the first email to the outcome, usually the person whose mailbox sent it, because that's where the host replies. A few rules keep a small team from tripping over itself:
- One owner per client. They decide which shows the client is pitched to and approve the angles.
- The sender answers. Replies go to whoever sent the pitch; if they're away, they hand over the thread, not just the task.
- Check before you pitch. Before adding a show, check whether anyone on the team has pitched it, for any client, in the last few months.
- Hand over in the record. The next step and its date are in the record, not in someone's head.
What Does a Weekly Podcast Outreach Routine Look Like?
A fixed rhythm beats heroic catch-up days. A routine that works for two or three people:
- Monday: answer every reply from the past few days first, then check delivery problems and the follow-ups due this week.
- Tuesday to Thursday: build shortlists and send new pitches, a steady batch per client rather than a burst.
- Every day: answer replies within a working day. A host who replied is the most valuable thing in the pipeline.
- Friday: update outcomes, snooze shows that went quiet, and note which angles got replies.
- End of the month: report bookings per client.
Which Numbers Should You Report to Clients?
Report outcomes, not activity: interviews booked, recorded and released per client, plus the conversations in progress. Pitch counts explain the effort but they're not the result. Use realistic expectations: at a 3.3% booking rate, it takes about 30 pitches per booking. Recommendations surface very high-fit podcasts, and pitches to very high-fit podcasts booked at 6.2%, compared with 3.3% overall (post-trial pitches from paying organizations, February 27 to June 28, 2026; observed results, not guarantees). See the podcast outreach benchmarks for the method.
Spreadsheet, Airtable, CRM, or a Podcast Outreach Tool?
Any of these can hold the record. The difference is how much of it you have to type and keep in sync yourself:
| Option | Good for | Where it gets hard |
|---|---|---|
| A shared spreadsheet | Free, and everyone knows it. Fine for one person and a few dozen pitches. | Every status and date is typed by hand, and replies stay in each person's inbox, so the sheet drifts from reality. |
| Airtable or Notion | Custom fields, views per teammate or client, and reminders. | You still copy emails, replies and dates in by hand, and there are no podcasts or contacts built in. |
| A sales CRM (such as HubSpot) | Logging emails and contacts, pipelines and reports. | Built around companies and deals, not shows and guests; podcast research happens elsewhere. |
| A podcast outreach workspace (Podseeker) | Finding shows, contacts, pitches, follow-ups, replies and outcomes in one place, sent from your own Gmail or Outlook. | A paid tool ($99 a month, 3 seats); built for podcast guesting, not for other kinds of outreach. |
A spreadsheet is the right start if you pitch a handful of shows a week. Once two or three people pitch several clients at once, the cost is the hours spent keeping the sheet true, and the follow-up that went to a host who had already replied.
How Small Agencies Run Podcast Outreach in Podseeker
Podseeker is a podcast database and outreach workspace. Each client has a profile, and the pitch record above is kept for you as you work:
| The job | In Podseeker |
|---|---|
| One record per client and show | Every pitch belongs to a client and a show, and All Pitches shows every pitch and reply across your clients in one list. |
| Don't pitch a show twice | Your team's activity on every podcast shows in search, and recommendations skip shows you've already pitched for that client. |
| Follow-ups on time | Schedule follow-ups for one pitch, a selection, or a whole campaign. A scheduled follow-up is cancelled if the host replies first, and campaign follow-ups skip pitches that are already conversations. |
| Know what needs attention | A Monday email lists the pitches that need you this week: replies waiting, delivery issues and follow-ups due. |
| Stages and outcomes | Replies come back into the pitch from your inbox. Mark a pitch Booked or Declined, or snooze it to come back later. |
| One client at a time | A campaign per client, with its own template, follow-ups and daily sending pace; pause it when the client needs to wait, and archive it when it's done. |
| Report results | Replies and bookings by client and by campaign in Analytics, and pitch exports to CSV. |
The Podseeker plan is $99 a month and includes 3 seats. Start a free trial (3 days, card required).
Frequently Asked Questions
How many follow-ups should you send to a podcast host?
Two: on day 3 and day 7 after the first email, in the same thread. After that, snooze the show for 3 to 6 months instead of sending more.
Should you track podcasts or pitches?
Pitches: the client and the show together. One show can be a fit for several clients over time, and each needs its own history and outcome.
Can two people at the agency pitch the same podcast?
Yes, for different clients and with spacing between them, but check first. Hosts notice when one agency pitches them twice in a week. A shared record, or Podseeker's team activity on each podcast, shows who pitched it and when.
What's the best tool to organize podcast outreach for a small agency?
For a few pitches a week, a shared spreadsheet or Airtable base is enough. For a team pitching several clients every week, a podcast outreach workspace such as Podseeker saves the manual tracking, because the research, pitches, follow-ups and replies happen in the same place.
How we got these numbers: the follow-up and reply figures come from State of Podcast Pitching 2026, and the booking rates from the podcast outreach benchmarks. See how we check our data.
Related Guides
Try us risk free with a FREE 3 days trial.
