In Search of an Argument

Publicly listed emails

insearchofanargument@gmail.com

Looking for the right person? Join Podseeker to find direct host and producer contacts and manage your podcast outreach.

Pass/Fail: Michigan's Grading Experiment and the Resilience Question

October 16, 2026

Finally, a real argument. The University of Michigan floated making first-semester freshman grades pass/fail — pitched as a way to ease the student mental-health crisis — and it lit a fire under this crew. Shelly spiraled (her word), Beth brought receipts and her two college-freshman relatives, Peggy took the devil’s-advocate seat, and what starts as a grading debate turns into a much bigger fight about resilience, college, and how we’ve raised a generation.If you’ve ever had a strong opinion...

The Odyssey, Comfort Rewatches, and Everywhere We're Going

September 20, 2026

It's been too long since the whole crew was together, so Peggy, Beth, John, and Shelly finally reconnect — and it turns into one of our warmest, most fun episodes. This is the one you put on to feel like you're back around the table with friends who genuinely like each other, trading strong opinions on what they're watching and swapping stories about where they're all headed next.There's a spirited defense of the comfort rewatch, and everyone's pick is a little revealing. John has quietly fin...

The Redemption Tour

August 09, 2026

Two years ago, John Mellencamp stood on a stage in Bloomington, got heckled to play the hits, and told the crowd exactly where they could put their requests. He wanted to play the new album. This is not that tour.This is the redemption tour — a looser, happier Mellencamp at Grand Rapids' brand-new Acrisure Amphitheater, chain-smoking through the greatest hits at 74 and blowing past the noise curfew by fifteen minutes just to spite it. Peggy's hosting, Beth's out, and in her seat is Peggy's ni...

Veridical · Medium booking difficulty · 100 - 1,000 listeners

Secret Third Thing · Medium booking difficulty · 100 - 1,000 listeners

How do I get in touch with In Search of an Argument?

In Search of an Argument is hosted by Jim Gentile and Shelly Cummings. Its publicly listed email is insearchofanargument@gmail.com. For guest bookings, the host or producer is usually the best person to reach. Podseeker helps you find direct host and producer contacts and pitch from your own inbox.

What is the email for In Search of an Argument?

The publicly listed email for In Search of an Argument: insearchofanargument@gmail.com.

How many listeners does In Search of an Argument have?

Podseeker estimates In Search of an Argument reaches 100 to 1,000 listeners per episode. Only the publisher has exact numbers.

Who is an ideal guest for In Search of an Argument?

In Search of an Argument typically books working professionals with real expertise. Typical guest background: A knowledgeable enthusiast, critic, writer, academic, or accessible commentator with a strong perspective on film, television, music, politics, or sports; a personal connection to the hosts can also fit. Recent guests include Jaime Haak.

How hard is it to get booked on In Search of an Argument?

Very low. It books a wide range of guests, so a guest with a relevant story and a clear idea has a strong chance.

What topics does In Search of an Argument cover?

Recent episodes cover Art, Popular Culture, Film, Politics, and Sports. Pitch an idea tied to one of these topics and mention a recent episode.