So, you're ready to get booked on podcasts, but the idea of paying a hefty retainer to a podcast booking agency doesn't feel right. Maybe you want more control over the message, or maybe you're a hands-on PR pro, founder, or consultant who prefers to build your own relationships.
You're not alone. Many people look for alternatives to traditional agencies. The good news is, there are powerful ways to manage your own podcast outreach effectively. The market is full of tools, from simple directories to automated "matchmaking" services.
But which approach is right for you? This guide breaks down the top alternatives to hiring a full-service agency and explains the pros and cons of each, so you can choose the workflow that best fits your PR goals.
The Rise of "Matchmaking" Platforms (e.g., MatchMaker.fm)
A popular alternative to agencies is using platforms that promise to automatically match guests with hosts, kind of like a dating app for podcasters.
- How it Works: You create a profile with your topics of expertise, and their algorithm suggests podcasts that are looking for guests like you (and vice-versa).
- The Pros: It can be a fast way to get initial activity, especially for new speakers or podcasters looking to fill slots. It lowers the barrier to entry.
- The Catch (and it's a big one): This approach often prioritizes quantity over quality. You're relying on an algorithm to understand the nuances of what makes a good PR fit. You might get a lot of "matches," but many will be low-quality, irrelevant, or not aligned with your brand. You won't get booked on a show like a BBC podcast with an automated match; that requires real, strategic outreach.
Using Public Directories (e.g., PodcastGuests.com)
Another common DIY approach is using public directories where you can list yourself as a guest or browse through lists of shows.
- How it Works: These platforms act as large-scale classifieds. You can search for shows and find some basic information.
- The Pros: They often have a free tier and can be a decent starting point for basic research.
- The Catch: These are often just static lists. The data can be outdated, contact information is frequently missing or generic, and you have no way to efficiently filter for shows that are actually a good fit for a professional PR campaign (e.g., active, guest-friendly, with a specific audience size). You'll spend most of your time doing manual vetting.
Hiring a Freelancer or Virtual Assistant (VA)
For those who want to offload the work without the high cost of an agency, hiring a freelancer or VA from platforms like Upwork can seem like a good middle ground.
- How it Works: You hire someone to manually research podcasts, find contact information, and send pitches on your behalf.
- The Pros: It can be more cost-effective than a full agency retainer and saves you from doing the manual work yourself.
- The Catch: The quality is entirely dependent on the skill of the individual. They often use the same manual, time-consuming methods (Google searches, sifting through directories) that you're trying to avoid. Without access to professional tools, they can still spend a lot of time on low-value tasks.
The All-in-One Podcast PR Platform (The Professional DIY Approach)
This is the alternative for PR pros and founders who want agency-level results with in-house control. Instead of relying on automated matches or manual grunt work, you use a dedicated platform built for the entire podcast outreach workflow.
- How it Works: A platform like Podseeker combines a comprehensive podcast database with a powerful podcast search engine and integrated pitching tools.
- Why It's a Better Alternative: It gives you full control and empowers you to build real relationships.
- You control the search: You're not relying on a "magic" algorithm. You can use nuanced keywords, search by guest names like "Richard Edelman," and apply PR-specific filters (audience size, location, guest status, verified contacts) to build your own highly targeted media list.
- You control the vetting: You see all the data upfront—recent topics, guest history, social reach—so you can decide if a show is a true strategic fit.
- You control the relationship: You find the verified contact info, craft a personalized pitch, and send it directly from your own email account. It's your outreach, your relationship.
Instead of getting matched with hundreds of irrelevant shows, a platform like Podseeker allows you to find and pitch the ten right shows that will actually move the needle for your brand.
Wrapping It Up: Choosing the Right Alternative for You
If you're looking for an alternative to a traditional podcast booking agency, the right choice depends on your goals. Matchmaking apps can generate activity, and freelancers can take tasks off your plate.
But if your goal is to build a strategic, repeatable PR process where you have full control over targeting and can build genuine relationships with high-value podcast hosts, a dedicated podcast PR platform is the most powerful and efficient alternative.
Ready to run your own professional outreach campaigns?
Try us risk free with a FREE 3 days trial.
