Least Chaotic Podcast Guest Booking Workflow for PR

If you're like many podcast booking agents, your workflow is chaotic.

You use different spreadsheets for different clients and hope you keep track of all of them correctly. It's a manual process that leads to burnout. One slip, and you can lose that client or that relationship with a podcast.

The stakes are high.

Most advice on the internet targets solo founders, creators, and hosts who manage several contacts, so their advice doesn't apply to you. You're managing multiple clients with multiple campaigns and goals, often juggling 200+ pitches across 5 clients simultaneously.

This article is a comprehensive guide to help you find the right podcasts for your clients and manage your entire campaign without losing your sanity.

Step 1: Finding the Right Podcasts for Your Clients

To find the right podcast, you need to use a podcast database. But not just any database. A normal database will dump irrelevant stats that will bore you to tears. Sometimes they're built for advertisers or marketers.

You need a database that's built to help you find, pitch, and track your podcast outreach in one place.

What Makes a Database Work for Booking Agents

The best databases for your work prioritize different things than general podcast tools:

  • Search interfaces that prioritize active shows with guests (not every podcast takes guests)
  • Key metrics upfront like monthly listener size, gender, location, YouTube and Instagram follows
  • Booking intelligence showing typical credentials, achievements, recent guests, and topics to help you evaluate if this is worth pitching

There are several great tools like Podchaser, ListenNotes, and Rephonic that can accomplish this task. We built Podseeker specifically with booking agents in mind, so we're obviously biased toward our approach.

The Qualification Reality Check

Here's what most workflow guides miss: qualification is everything. You can't pitch every show you find. You need a system to quickly assess if a show is worth your time.

Look for these red flags:

  • No guest episodes in the last 3 months (they might have stopped taking guests)
  • Wildly inconsistent publishing schedule (shows that aren't serious about their podcast)
  • No clear contact information (if you can't find how to contact the podcast host, move on)

Green flags that signal a good target:

  • Recent guests with similar credentials to your client
  • Consistent publishing schedule (weekly or bi-weekly)
  • Engaged audience (comments, reviews, social media activity)

Step 2: Curate the Right Podcasts with a Smart List

Once you find the right podcasts, you want to curate them for different campaigns.

You can always start with the trusty old spreadsheet. It's easy, familiar, and most importantly, it gets you started.

But once you're juggling multiple campaigns, it might be time to use a tool.

The Spreadsheet Approach (Enhanced)

If you decide to use spreadsheets, create a new one for each campaign/client. This allows you to use different tabs to manage the different lifecycle stages.

Keep it simple but comprehensive with these tracking columns:

  • Column 1: Podcast title name
  • Column 2: Status (to pitch, pitched, replied, booked, rejected, follow up later)
  • Column 3: Pitch template (AI expert pitch, founder story pitch, etc.)
  • Column 4: Last contacted (so you can sort and follow up)
  • Column 5: Decision maker (host vs. producer - this matters for follow-ups)
  • Column 6: Booking timeline (some shows book 6 months out)
  • Column 7: Notes (great for client x, follow up later, want to book, not a good time, loves fintech guests, etc.)

The All-in-One Platform Approach

Tools like Podseeker handle a lot of the complexity for you:

  • Collaborate on shared media lists so you and your colleagues can divide and conquer
  • No double pitching to the same podcasts. See which podcast you've already pitched to and avoid the embarrassment of double pitching
  • Relationship tracking so you remember "pitched in March, follow up in Q3" or "loves fintech guests, save for next fintech client"

Step 3: Have Pitch Templates for Different Clients and Campaigns

Having different podcast pitch examples allows you to somewhat "personalize" each pitch.

For example, you can have a "[topic] expert pitch," a "founder story pitch," etc. You can then update the subject, names, topics, etc.

You'll still have to do your research on each show and at least fill in the blanks.

The Client Expectation Reality

Here's what nobody talks about: client expectation management is part of your workflow. When a client wants to be on Joe Rogan but their expertise is B2B SaaS, you need a system for having that conversation.

Create tiers in your pitching strategy:

  • Tier 1: Dream shows (low success rate, high impact)
  • Tier 2: Realistic targets (good success rate, solid impact)
  • Tier 3: Sure bets (high success rate, moderate impact)

Pitch all three, but set expectations accordingly.

AI-Powered Personalization

At Podseeker, we use AI to do deep podcast pitch personalization for you, saving you hours of research time. Our pitch tool blends the show's recent topics, guests, and your client's bio/profile to create a personalized pitch.

You can even customize the AI template and prompt to fit your style and templates.

Step 4: Managing Campaigns (The Make-or-Break Stage)

You've curated a list of highly relevant podcasts and sent them pitches. Now it's time to manage your campaigns.

That means managing follow-ups, bookings, replies, and the inevitable chaos of 3 clients wanting to pitch the same show.

Follow-Up Cadences That Actually Work

Most guides tell you to follow up, but they don't tell you when or how. Here's what works:

  • First follow-up: 1 week after initial pitch
  • Second follow-up: 2 weeks after first follow-up
  • Third follow-up: 1 month after second (with new angle or topic)
  • Long-term follow-up: 3-6 months later with different client or topic

Handling Rejections Like a Pro

Not all "no" responses are created equal:

  • Soft no: "Not right now" or "maybe in the future" (follow up in 3-6 months)
  • Hard no: "Not a good fit" or "we don't take guests" (remove from list)
  • Conditional no: "Love the guest but not this topic" (save for future with different angle)

Staying on Top of Updates

If you're using a spreadsheet, make sure you update the status of each pitch so you don't lose track.

If you do lose track, maybe once a week or month, you'll need to do a full sync just in case you forget to update the spreadsheet. Hey, you're busy. Sometimes a prospect replies and you reply immediately without updating your spreadsheet. It happens.

All-in-One Campaign Management

If you use an all-in-one platform like Podseeker, you'll be able to see all your pitches on one page. You can see when they open your email, if they replied, and also directly reply from there.

Everything is done by connecting your mailbox so it looks like it's coming from you, not some marketing automation software.

Common Workflow Bottlenecks (And How to Fix Them)

The Volume Problem

You're managing 200+ pitches across multiple clients. It's impossible to remember every conversation, every follow-up, every relationship nuance.

Solution: Build systems, not just lists. Use tags, categories, and notes religiously. If you can't scale your memory, scale your documentation.

The Conflict Problem

Three clients want to pitch the same show. Who goes first? How do you handle it?

Solution: Create a client priority system and booking calendar. First come, first served usually works, but have the conversation upfront about how you handle conflicts.

The Relationship Problem

You're not just pitching once - you're building long-term relationships with producers and hosts. But how do you track "this host loves fintech guests" across multiple campaigns?

Solution: Use a CRM mindset. Track preferences, response patterns, and relationship history. "Always replies on Fridays" is as valuable as an email address.

Step 5: Reports and ROI (What Clients Actually Care About)

The hard part is done and you got your clients booked on podcasts.

Yay! It went splendid and they got featured on Forbes, CNN, etc.

Your client is satisfied, but you want to be able to send a report to them to prove that you're worth every penny, and maybe more.

Beyond Reach Numbers

Most clients don't care about reach numbers. They want business impact. Here's what to track:

  • Episode links for client portfolios (they use these for credibility)
  • Mention traffic/leads (did the podcast appearance drive business?)
  • Message consistency (are they staying on brand across appearances?)
  • Relationship building (introductions made, connections formed)

Simple Summary Reports Work Best

Send them a nice report of the podcasts you got them booked on and the impact. A simple summary is great.

For example, July 2025 summary:

  • 8 podcasts booked
  • Potential reach: 100,000 (12,500 listeners per month × 8 podcasts)
  • Social reach: 1,000,000 (125,000 YouTube/Instagram followers × 8 podcasts)
  • Business impact: 3 qualified leads, 2 speaking opportunities, 1 partnership discussion

If you use a good podcast database, you'll be able to quickly get these numbers. (Hint: we do.)

Scaling Without Losing Your Mind

The Prioritization Framework

Not all shows are worth the same effort. Use this framework:

High-effort pitches: Tier 1 shows with complex personalization requirementsMedium-effort pitches: Tier 2 shows with template customizationLow-effort pitches: Tier 3 shows with minimal personalization

Match your energy to the opportunity.

The Quality vs. Volume Balance

You can't maintain boutique-level personalization at scale. But you can't send generic blasts either.

Find the middle ground: deep personalization for dream shows, smart templates for everything else.

Wrapping Up

That's it. That's the workflow for podcast bookings.

Have a system. Stick to it. Update it and make your clients happy.

The key is understanding that this isn't just about finding podcasts and sending emails. It's about managing relationships, expectations, and chaos at scale.

If you want an all-in-one platform to help you manage this complexity, try Podseeker for free.

Oky Sabeni

Product marketer focus on product, tech, and marketing

Get your clients booked on top podcasts

Try us risk free with a FREE 3 days trial.

Start Your Free Trial

Related Articles