Hiring a Podcast Booking Agency? Ask These 5 Questions First

So, you're ready to get booked on podcasts, and you're thinking about hiring a professional podcast booking agency to make it happen. It can be a great investment to save time and leverage expertise. But not all agencies or podcast PR services are created equal.

Before you sign a contract and hand over a hefty retainer, you need to vet them like you would any critical hire. Asking the right questions upfront can be the difference between a successful campaign and months of wasted budget.

Here are the five essential questions you should ask any potential podcast booking agency, and what to look for in their answers.

Question 1: "What is your process for finding relevant podcasts?"

A great agency doesn't just pull from a stale, pre-made list. Their value comes from a dynamic discovery and vetting process.

• What to Listen For: A good answer should involve using a comprehensive podcast database, not just browsing public directories. They should talk about using specific filters to find shows that match your niche, your target audience, and your specific campaign goals.
• Red Flags: If they sound vague, talk about "their network" without specifics, or can't explain how they filter for things like active shows or guest-friendliness, be cautious.
• The Professional Standard: Top-tier agencies and in-house pros use dedicated tools like Podseeker to perform advanced searches, filtering by nuanced keywords, guest history, and audience data to build a highly targeted list.

Question 2: "How do you qualify a podcast before pitching?"

Finding a list of shows is just the start. Qualifying them is what separates the pros from the amateurs.

• What to Listen For: They should talk about looking beyond the podcast title. A great answer will include reviewing recent episode topics and guest history to ensure relevance, checking audience size estimates and social reach to gauge influence, and verifying that the show is a good cultural fit for your brand.
• Red Flags: If their process is just "we check if the category matches," they're not doing deep enough work to protect your client's brand or ensure a good ROI.
• The Professional Standard: An agency should be able to provide you with a vetted list of opportunities, complete with the data to back up why each show is a good fit.

Question 3: "How do you get contact information, and what's your approach to pitching?"

This question gets to the heart of their execution and is crucial for protecting your brand's reputation.

• What to Listen For: A great agency has a process for finding verified, up-to-date contact information for hosts and producers. Their pitching philosophy must be centered on personalization. They should talk about crafting a unique angle for each show by researching recent episodes and guests, and focusing on the value your client brings to their audience.
• Red Flags: If they use vague terms like "our proprietary list" without explaining how it's maintained, be wary. If they talk about "mass outreach" or using a single template for hundreds of shows, they're a volume shop, not a strategic partner.
• The Professional Standard: Modern agencies use a platform like Podseeker to access a constantly refreshed podcast database for contacts. They also use tools that allow for deep personalization. For example, our podcast pitch tool generates a tailored first draft by blending client info with a show's recent data. Crucially, it allows the agent to edit every part of the pitch—subject and body—to add that final human touch and ensure the message is perfect before sending.

Question 4: "How do you handle the sending and tracking of outreach?"

The logistics of sending and tracking can make or break a campaign. This is where you separate the pros from those using messy spreadsheets.

• What to Listen For: They should describe a centralized system. Do they send from their own agency email, or can they send on behalf of your client from their address for authenticity? How do they track who has opened the email, who has replied, and when it's time to follow up?
• Red Flags: If the answer is "we use a big spreadsheet" or "we just keep track in our email," it's a sign of an inefficient and error-prone process.
• The Professional Standard: A top-tier agency or in-house pro uses a platform that integrates directly with their email (like Google or Outlook). In Podseeker, for instance, you can send a test email to yourself first to approve the final look and feel. When the real pitch goes out, it comes directly from your email address, and all opens, replies, and follow-ups are tracked automatically in one clean dashboard. This provides full transparency and ensures no opportunity is missed.

Question 5: "How will you report on progress and results?"

You're investing in a service; you need to know how success will be measured and communicated.

• What to Listen For: A clear answer about reporting cadence (e.g., weekly, bi-weekly) and the metrics they track. This should include both activity metrics (pitches sent, open rates, response rates) and outcome metrics (interviews booked, episodes live).
• Red Flags: Vague answers like "we'll keep you updated" without a clear structure for reporting.
• The Professional Standard: Professionals use a system where they can easily see the status of every pitch in their pipeline. They should be able to provide clear reports on what's working and where the opportunities are. With tools like Podseeker, they can manage and view the status of entire campaigns, making reporting to clients straightforward and data-driven.

The DIY Alternative: The Modern Approach for Founders, Authors & PR Pros

After considering the costs and process, you might realize that a full-service agency isn't the right fit. Maybe you want more direct control over your message, or agency retainers (often $2,000-$5,000+ per month) are out of budget.

The good news is, you no longer need an agency to run a professional, agency-level podcast outreach campaign.

This is the ideal path for:

• Startup Founders & Solo Entrepreneurs: Who need to build authority and reach niche audiences efficiently.
• Authors, Coaches, and Experts: Who want to promote their work and build their personal brand directly.
• Hands-on PR Professionals & Small Agencies: Who want to deliver top-tier results for their clients with a powerful, cost-effective workflow.

The key to a successful DIY approach is having the right platform. A tool like Podseeker gives you the same capabilities the pros use: a comprehensive podcast database, advanced search and filtering, and an integrated pitching and tracking system. It empowers you to be your own podcast booking agent, with full control over the process at a fraction of the cost.

Ready to run your outreach like a top-tier agency?

>> Start Your Free Trial and Access Professional PR Tools <<