So you've decided to get your client booked on podcasts. Great call. It's one of the most effective ways to build authority and reach engaged audiences. But there's a huge difference between deciding to do podcast outreach and succeeding at it.
Too many PR campaigns start with a good intention and end with a spreadsheet of unanswered emails and wasted hours. Why? Because they fall into a few common, completely avoidable traps.
This isn't about blaming anyone. It's about recognizing that podcast outreach is a specific skill. It's not traditional media relations, and it's not a numbers game like cold email. Let's walk through the five mistakes that sink most podcast outreach campaigns and talk about how to do it the right way.
Mistake #1: Pitching the Wrong Podcasts
This is, without a doubt, the number one reason pitches get ignored. You wouldn't pitch a B2B SaaS story to a lifestyle magazine, but every day, podcast hosts get pitches that are wildly irrelevant to their show.
- The Problem: You choose podcasts based on broad categories ("Business," "Health") or vanity metrics (a huge follower count) without checking if the show's specific niche and audience actually match your client. A pitch for a financial advisor gets sent to a podcast for broke college students. It's a waste of everyone's time.
- How to Fix It: Get granular from the start. Your job isn't just to find podcasts; it's to qualify them. Before you even think about pitching, you need to know a show's specific topics, their typical guests, and their estimated audience size. Is it an active show? Do they even feature guests?
- The Podseeker Shortcut: This is exactly what a professional podcast search tool is for. Instead of just searching "health," you can search for a nuanced keyword like "palliative care," then filter for shows that are active, have guests, and have an audience size that fits your campaign goals. This initial vetting saves you from the biggest mistake in the book.
Mistake #2: Sending a Generic, Inauthentic Pitch
Podcast hosts are not faceless media outlets; they're creators who care about their show and their community. A generic, copy-paste pitch is the fastest way to get your email deleted.
- The Problem: Your pitch reads like a press release. It's all about your client ("My client, Jane Doe, is an expert...") and has zero indication that you know anything about the podcast you're pitching.
- How to Fix It: Personalization is everything. Your pitch needs to show you've done your homework. Reference a specific recent episode. Mention a guest they had on that you enjoyed. Explain why your client's expertise would be valuable to their specific listeners. It's about them, not you. For inspiration, check out these proven podcast pitch examples.
- The Podseeker Shortcut: Our podcast pitch tool helps you scale personalization. It generates tailored drafts by blending your client's bio with data from the podcast's recent topics and guests. It gets you 99% of the way there, so you can focus on adding that final, authentic touch that builds a real connection.
Mistake #3: Having No Clear Goals or KPIs
"We want to get booked on podcasts" is not a strategy. It's a wish. Without clear goals, you can't measure success or justify the time and effort.
- The Problem: You pitch a bunch of shows with no clear objective. You land a booking, but you have no idea if it actually helped your client's business. Was the goal brand awareness? Lead generation? Website traffic?
- How to Fix It: Before you start, define what success looks like. If it's brand awareness, you'll target shows with larger audiences. If it's lead generation, you'll need to prepare a specific call to action or lead magnet for your client to mention during the interview.
Mistake #4: Ignoring the Host's Preferred Process
This is a simple one, but so many people get it wrong. You craft the perfect email and send it... to an address that no one checks, or to a host who only accepts submissions through a form.
- The Problem: You annoy the host or producer by not respecting their workflow. Your perfectly crafted pitch ends up in the digital trash can because it wasn't submitted correctly.
- How to Fix It: Always check the podcast's website first. Look for a "Be a Guest," "Contact," or "Submissions" page. If they provide a specific form or a dedicated email address for pitches, use it.
- The Podseeker Shortcut: Our podcast database doesn't just give you any email; we prioritize verified contacts and, where available, provide direct links to guest submission forms. We help you contact podcast hosts the way they want to be contacted.
Mistake #5: No Follow-Up (or Bad Follow-Up)
You send one great pitch and hear nothing back. So you move on. This is leaving bookings on the table.
- The Problem: Hosts are busy. Your email gets buried. They meant to reply but got distracted. A single email has a high chance of getting lost.
- How to Fix It: A polite, brief follow-up a week later is professional persistence, not annoying spam. Remind them of the core value proposition. Don't send more than one or two follow-ups, but don't give up after the first try.
- The Podseeker Shortcut: When you send pitches through Podseeker, we track opens and replies. You know who has seen your email, which helps you time your follow-up perfectly. You can manage the entire outreach sequence from one dashboard, ensuring no opportunity slips through the cracks.
Wrapping It Up: Pitching Smarter, Not Just Harder
Avoiding these common mistakes is what separates successful podcast outreach from frustrating, low-ROI efforts. It comes down to a professional workflow: Find the right targets, personalize your outreach, respect the host's process, and follow up intelligently.
Tools like Podseeker are designed to streamline this entire process, helping you avoid these pitfalls and focus on what you do best: building relationships and landing great placements for your clients.
Ready to find and pitch the right way?
>> Start Your Free Trial and Explore Podseeker's Workflow Tools <<
Try us risk free with a FREE 3 days trial.
